US court bars AI-enhanced evidence in triple murder case
A Washington state judge has ruled against the use of artificial intelligence-enhanced video evidence in a triple murder trial.
King County Superior Court Judge Leroy McCullogh says this is due to concerns over what he called the technology’s “novelty” and “opacity.”
The unprecedented decision stems from a case involving mobile phone footage, enhanced by AI, in a self-defense claim.
Prosecutors opposed the technology, citing a lack of legal precedent.
Despite the defense’s use of AI to improve footage, the developer cautioned against its forensic use.
Forensic analysts have highlighted disparities and inaccuracies in AI-enhanced videos, raising doubts about their reliability.
Experts have stressed the need for rigorous research and standards before AI’s widespread adoption in legal settings.
While AI has shown promise in investigative uses, such as clarifying license plate images, concerns persist regarding its suitability for legal evidence.